Publications

Interactions between the European Emissions Trading System and Complementary Energy Policies

1 January 1970 - Special issues - By : Sylvain CAIL (ENERDATA) / Andrea BLANCO TORO

I4CE – Institute for Climate Economics and Enerdata publish an article in the French Review of Energy N° 628, in November-December 2015.

After three Phases of functioning, the EU ETS meets new challenges in preparation of its Phase IV. Indeed on July 15th, the European Commission published a proposal for a revision of the EU ETS Directive for the post 2020 period. This proposal provides a 43% emissions reduction target for the EU ETS and a linear reduction factor increased to 2.2% from 2021. This new ambition is embedded in an energy and climate package composed with a binding 40% GHG reduction compared to 1990, a binding 27% share of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) in gross final energy consumption, and an indicative 27% energy efficiency (EE) improvement compared to 2007 baseline – both without any binding targets for Member States. Such a design of the energy and climate policies package raises the issue of interactions between these policies and their impacts on the EU ETS, presented as the central pillar of the European climate policy.

This article aims at examining, in a first section, interactions between the EU ETS and complementary energy policies during Phases II and III and their consequences on European allowances (EUA) surplus. Then, results from the POLES model provide an assessment of energy and climate policies in the EU up to 2030, with only a GHG emissions target and further with additional RES and EE targets. Based on lessons from the 2020 energy and climate package, recommendations are provided to manage interactions between the EU ETS and complementary energy policies in order to improve the cost-effectiveness.

  • An unique GHG emission reduction target may allow achieving the decarbonization objective at lower cost. The combination of different objectives may have significant impacts on the cost of transition to a low carbon economy.
  • However, complementary instruments are necessary because of a wide array of barriers to entry hampering to exploit the full decarbonisation potential at lower cost in the short and long term. Besides, carbon prices are not always able to encourage sufficient innovation and diffusion of clean technologies because of the inability to appropriate the full benefits of innovation –so called technology spill-over market failures.
  • The impact of the whole set of instruments on the carbon price should be however carefully assessed and justified in a transparent and comprehensive manner.
  • Drawing on the 2020 EU energy and climate framework lessons, where energy efficiency measures and permits offsets account for more than half of the surplus, the EU ETS cap setting should account for these instruments.
  • Some flexibility is necessary in the supply of allowances to improve the resilience of the EU ETS. The correct balance must be found between improving long term predictability so as to increase investor confidence, and increasing flexibility for greater stabilization. The Market Stability Reserve has been adopted, and its efficiency at addressing this issue needs to be analyzed carefully.

To find the article

 

 

Interactions between the European Emissions Trading System and Complementary Energy Policies
To learn more
  • 11/27/2024 Blog post
    Climate investments in Europe must double, and the clock is ticking

    To tackle the challenges of competitiveness and well-being of future generations, Europe needs to accelerate the climate transition. This will require sizable investment, both public and private. National governments must thus embrace and the EU must facilitate investments in climate transition. As the next European Commission prepares to take office, the challenges facing the College are stark. The recent report by Mario Draghi makes clear that there is an urgent need to invest in European competitiveness and innovation, while accelerating the decarbonization of the continent’s economy, to avoid a “slow agony of decline” for the block.

  • 11/08/2024 Foreword of the week
    COP29: From ambition to action

    This coming Monday will see the start of COP29 – formally the 29th session of the Conference of the Parties to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), in Baku, Azerbaijan. The edition is nicknamed “the finance COP” and is important on more than one account, not least as Trump’s victory likely leads to a change of course for the US on climate commitment.

    The volume and structure of the finance mobilised to support developing countries to transition to low-emission and climate-resilient economies tops the agenda.

  • 10/28/2024
    French Observatory of Access Conditions to the Ecological Transition, 2024 Edition

    The ecological transition can only happen if all households have access to solutions – public transport, electric vehicles, home insulation, heating upgrades, etc. The issue of the access to transition solutions is therefore crucial for climate policies. Special attention should be paid to low- and middle-income households, as the necessary investments may not be sustainable for them. 

See all publications
Press contact Amélie FRITZ Head of Communication and press relations Email
Subscribe to our mailing list :
I register !
Subscribe to our newsletter
Once a week, receive all the information on climate economics
I register !
Fermer