The limitations of voluntary climate commitments from private financial actors

24 November 2022 - Climate Brief - By : Michel CARDONA

Private finance will not fund the transition without a major commitment from public authorities


For several years, and particularly since COP 26, considerable time and energy has been dedicated to the subject of voluntary commitments from private financial actors. These commitments, made within the framework of international initiatives, are expected to enable private finance to be mobilized for the transition to a carbon neutral economy.


Such initiatives, however, encounter powerful structural obstacles that limit their effectiveness. While beneficial and worthy of encouragement, we cannot expect these initiatives to deliver more than they are realistically capable of achieving. Indeed, while they can accompany actors already engaged in economic transformation, they are incapable of making a more decisive contribution to the transition.


This observation leads us to call for a strong commitment from public authorities. This commitment, just like for other economic agents, will be essential to mobilize private finance to support a rapid and organized transition.



According to Mark Carney’s statements at COP 26, the Glasgow Finance Alliance for Net Zero – GFANZ, a voluntary coalition of 500 financial actors with $130 trillion in assets – was destined to be a game-changer in financing the transition to a carbon neutral economy.


But should we rely on this voluntary approach? The answer presented in this Climate Brief is no. Although useful and led by people who are truly committed to the cause, we cannot expect too much from these initiatives to mobilize private financial actors in favour of the transition, given the limited effectiveness of voluntary commitments. Conversely, an approach based on the strong commitment of public authorities seems essential.


This public commitment must be based on a wide range of instruments, including financial regulation, whose role is essential when it comes to financial actors.


The first section of this document analyses what we can realistically expect from financial actors in terms of funding the transition. The second section presents the reasons why voluntary private initiatives cannot play a decisive role, despite the impressive volume of assets managed by the actors who have made these commitments. The third section returns to the decisive role of public authorities in mobilizing private finance.


This report is part of the Finance ClimAct project and was produced with the contribution of the European Union LIFE programme. This work reflects only the views of I4CE – Institute for Climate Economics. Other members of the Finance ClimAct Consortium and the European Commission are not responsible for any use that may be made of the information it contains.



The limitations of voluntary climate commitments from private financial actors pdf
I4CE Contacts
Associate Expert - Financial Sector, Risks and Climate Change Email
To learn more
  • 11/28/2019
    Finance fit for Paris (3fP) – Results and scores for France

    The global community needs to transform the world economy to become low-carbon and climate resilient. This is the commitment made by the international community in the Paris Climate Agreement. However, humanity needs to find a way to finance this goal. The European Commission estimates that a funding gap of at least EUR 180bn p.a. exist […]

  • 11/24/2022
    Implementing prudential transition plans for banks: what are the expexted impacts?

    The European Union has made rapid progress on the issue of transition plans for companies and banks. First of all, the CSRD directive obliges each listed company to publish its plan for achieving carbon neutrality by 2050. Published by EFRAG this summer, the standards set for these plans can be considered ambitious and commensurate with the challenges they face. With regards to banks, it is now clear that they will be required to publish their transition plan. What remains under debate is whether these transition plans should be integrated into prudential regulations, which would open the way to numerous possibilities of action and sanctions by supervisors.

  • 02/01/2018 Blog post
    I4CE welcomes the publication of the Final Report of the EU High Level Expert Group on Sustainable Finance

    Following a year of meetings, consultations and discussions, the EU High-Level Group on Sustainable Finance (HLEG) released today its recommendations on the actions needed to make the EU financial system more sustainable. 2017 was a busy year in the sustainable finance community with the publication of the conclusions of the G20 Green Finance study group and the Taskforce on Climate-related Financial Disclosure (TCFD) – and concluded with the Paris One Planet Summit. The publication of this report demonstrates the will of policymakers and market actors to move from discussions to actions in 2018 and take concrete steps to help the financial system take into account climate change, as well as broader environmental and social considerations

See all publications
Press contact Amélie FRITZ Head of Communication and press relations Email
Subscribe to our mailing list :
I register !
Subscribe to our newsletter
Once a week, receive all the information on climate economics
I register !