Publications Investment Public finance

Investing in climate can help France drive its economic recovery

10 April 2020 - Climate Report - By : Hadrien HAINAUT / Quentin PERRIER, PhD / Benoît LEGUET / Maxime LEDEZ

Confronted with a health crisis that has caused a global social and economic shock, the European Union and countries around the world are adopting major economic support programs. Following the initial focus that must be on overcoming the health emergency itself, actions that contribute to climate goals can be an effective part of improving both the economy and the resilience of our society. I4CE’s proposal calls for a public finance package of 7 billion euros per year that is estimated to trigger 19 billion euros of additional public and private investment. Altogether, this package would contribute to the economic recovery post-crisis, while simultaneously reinforcing our society against future shocks without reducing France’s contribution to international climate goals.  



Responding to the health emergency, protecting the economy and recovering from the COVID-19 crisis

France is facing a health crisis that is causing a global economic shock. Economic experts do not yet fully comprehend this shock due to the high number of unknowns. Indeed, growth, unemployment and debt are being subjected to an unprecedented public health crisis.


Beyond this “economic resuscitation” phase, a crisis recovery strategy will have to be deployed by mobilizing public policy, particularly public investment capacity and taxation. In France, the recovery strategy’s effectiveness will also depend on the coordination of national and European responses.


I4CE are convinced that climate action is not an obstacle to a crisis recovery, but an effective response to the demand for resilience that is likely to emerge in European societies. For this reason, I4CE contends that a recovery package must prioritize those policies and actions that support outcomes in three areas:


  1. Environment: by maintaining the credibility of the Green Deal, by preserving the industrial capital of low-carbon sectors, by adapting our economy to climate change;
  2. Economy: by contributing to the revival of activities in the short term while simultaneously reducing exposure to future crises: oil price shocks, food and industrial supply, etc.;
  3. Health: by reducing the vulnerability of society to health threats, particularly through the improvement of air quality and reduction of fuel poverty.



Staying on Track with the France’s Climate Goals

Even in view of the major economic shock ahead, the French National Low-Carbon Strategy (SNBC) remains a useful and essential benchmark for developing a pro-climate  economic recovery package. The strategy sets out how France plans to reduce its greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from each sector through 2030. Drawn up by the government following consultations with stakeholders and revised last year, it has also been communicated to Europe and to the signatories of the Paris Agreement.


I4CE has looked at seven sectors that are particularly significant because they account for two-thirds of the France’s low-carbon investment. For each sector, I4CE has assessed the investment objectives expressed in the SNBC and has proposed pro-climate pro-recovery measures, together with a financing plan that assesses the contributions of governments, companies, households and financial institutions.


These sectors are: (1) retrofitting of private housing, (2) retrofitting of tertiary buildings (public and private), (3) deployment of low-emission passenger vehicles, (4) urban public transport infrastructure, (5) rail infrastructure, (6) cycle paths and network, and (7) renewable electricity generation.


I4CE recognizes that the SNBC and PPE represent more than just investments in these sectors, and that essential public action is needed in other areas. I4CE also recognizes that action taken to reduce GHG emissions does not preclude the need to adapt buildings, infrastructure and equipment to climate change.



A 7 billion euros per year public stimulus package to trigger 19 billion euros in additional annual investment


Click on this button to see the image


  • The French State should increase the existing level of support for climate investment an additional 4.3 billion euros per year. This should be made up of 1.3 billion euros for off taking guarantees for renewable electricity producers and 3.0 billion euros for the co-financing of households, companies and local governments that undertake new investments;
  • Local governments should increase current levels of investment and co-financing by 2.1 billion euros per year. This increase could be financed with limited to no impact on their budgets through the use of by project-specific instruments, such as national grants, white certificates (Certificats d’économies d’énergie, CEEs) or loans from public and commercial banks.
  • State-owned banks should increase by 2.3 billion euros per year their new commitments to businesses, local governments and project companies.


Over and above these actions, energy suppliers, public infrastructure management companies (such as RATP and SNCF Réseau), co-financed by public authorities and borrowing from banks and financial markets, should increase annual investments.

To learn more
  • 06/09/2023 Foreword of the week
    Green Deal: chapter 2

    Emmanuel Macron certainly made a mistake in calling for a European “regulatory pause” on the environment. In the same speech, he however expressed a truth that is essential to the debate: “Europe and France risk being the best-in-class in terms of regulation, and the worst-in-class in terms of financing”. It went unnoticed but, as highlighted in this I4CE newsletter, the time has come for a debate on how the EU can better finance the climate transition. And there is no time like the present! In precisely one year, on June 9th 2024, hundreds of millions of Europeans will vote for a new European Parliament, that will in term elect a new European Commission that will negotiate the future EU budget.

  • 06/08/2023 Blog post Op-ed
    Climate investment: working with our differences

    How much should France invest in climate action ? Experts from diverse backgrounds have sought to answer this important and seemingly simple question. They agree that France needs to invest more to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions. But they differ on the scale of public and private funding needs, which range from €20 to €100 billion a year. Is this a cause for concern? Not really, because the experts are not counting the same thing. These differences can be explained and should not be used as an excuse for inaction.

  • 06/08/2023 Blog post
    Can France finance the transition only with budget savings?

    How does the government plan to finance the increase in its public spending on climate action? Further to the government’s reactions to the Pisani-Ferry report, which proposes using all options, including debt and tax increases, let us make an assumption: what if the government were to rely solely on budget saving options? I4CE’s Damien Demailly reviews the savings options available to the government. Clearly, they are all difficult to implement and some may prove counterproductive. They are nevertheless on the government’s agenda and are worth explaining and discussing, as are all options to finance the transition.

See all publications
Press contact Amélie FRITZ Head of Communication and press relations Email
Subscribe to our mailing list :
I register !
Subscribe to our newsletter
Once a week, receive all the information on climate economics
I register !